Inherited Jewelry: Sell or Keep?

Are you wondering what to do with inherited jewelry? You’re probably not alone.

Receiving jewelry as an inheritance is an event that can evoke mixed emotions. On one hand, there are the memories of a loved one, the sentimental value, and the desire to keep alive the memory of someone to whom we may have been deeply attached. On the other hand, there might be the desire to rid ourselves of that very kind of reminder, which could potentially bring painful memories. Finally, there may be the legitimate wish to monetize the inheritance.

In these situations, doubts about family jewelry can arise: is that piece of jewelry we've seen on our deceased relative for years valuable, or is it just symbolic? And the jewelry that’s kept in a chest and passed down from generation to generation — does it have real economic value, or is it merely a family heirloom? Should you keep it or sell it?

In this guide, we will explore the various available options, helping you understand how to handle the jewelry you’ve inherited and what choices you can make based on your personal situation.

The First Step: Appraising the Jewelry

When faced with the decision of whether to keep or sell a piece of family jewelry, it is crucial not to make hasty decisions driven solely by impulse. Taking a thoughtful approach will help avoid any regrets. In general, the first step when inheriting one or more pieces of jewelry is to have them appraised. It is essential to understand the market value of a piece before making any decisions.

Most people are unsure how to identify valuable inherited jewelry. Items that may have high market value are often undervalued, while pieces with little economic worth are sometimes estimated based on sentimental value, which unfortunately has no impact on price. A professional appraisal is therefore indispensable, both to avoid undervaluing the jewelry and to make informed decisions.

Advice on Inherited Jewelry: Who to Turn to?

To verify the authenticity of inherited jewelry, you can consult:

A certified gemologist for a technical and professional evaluation.
A trusted jeweler, especially one with experience in vintage jewelry.
An auction expert, if you suspect the pieces may be historical or of high value.

These professionals, in addition to verifying the authenticity of the stones, will also be able to provide estimates and offer advice on how to proceed. If you have certificates of authenticity or other documentation, it’s a good idea to bring them along during the appraisal; they can help facilitate the estimate and, in some cases, increase the perceived value.

Keeping Inherited Jewelry: When It's the Right Choice

Inherited jewelry doesn’t necessarily have to be sold. In many cases, choosing not to sell a family heirloom is the wisest decision, especially when the sentimental value far outweighs its economic worth.

Jewelry with sentimental or economic value is more than just a material possession: it represents stories, people, and significant moments. Their true value lies in the fact that they are passed down through generations, becoming central to family narratives, dreams, and memories. A grandmother’s ring, a necklace passed down from generation to generation... These items are priceless because they carry with them an emotional legacy that cannot be replaced. Keeping them is an act of love and respect.

cosa fare con gioielli ereditati

Long-Term Value: Jewelry as an Investment

Naturally, the decision to keep a piece of jewelry rather than sell it can also be driven by economic reasons. Diamonds, gold, and certain rare gemstones can appreciate in value over time, especially if kept in good condition, and may therefore be considered an investment for the future. If you don't require immediate liquidity, it may be worthwhile to preserve them and eventually pass them on to your heirs.

If you wish to preserve your jewelry as a long-term asset, remember to:

Store them in padded cases, away from direct light and humidity.
Avoid contact with perfumes or harsh cleaning agents.
Perform regular maintenance with a jeweler.
Occasionally have them appraised to monitor their value.

Selling Inherited Jewelry: A Personal Choice

There is no one-size-fits-all rule for managing inherited jewelry. The decision to keep or sell a family heirloom is up to you, your personal situation (both financial and emotional), the value (both economic and sentimental) of the piece, and, most importantly, your connection to it. Generally speaking, selling may make sense if:

You need liquidity for urgent expenses or investments.
The piece doesn't match your tastes and you are unlikely to wear it.
You've inherited multiple pieces, and therefore selling one doesn’t come with regrets.
The economic value of the jewelry is significantly appealing.
Keeping the piece is more painful than selling it.
You wish to make your own will and need to divide the proceeds from the sale among several beneficiaries.

Where to Sell Inherited Jewelry?

If you’ve decided to sell, here are some options for where to do so:

Jewelry Stores: Great for quick sales, but they often offer lower prices.
Auction Houses: Ideal for rare or antique jewelry that could fetch high prices. Be sure to account for the lengthy timelines involved.
Specialized Online Platforms: Offer international visibility, but require caution to avoid scams.

In general, to avoid selling your jewelry at too low a price, always get a preliminary appraisal, request multiple estimates and compare them, and work exclusively with trusted professionals, preferably with good reviews or references.

A Balanced Approach: Selling Part of Your Jewelry

If you want to monetize your inherited jewelry but feel uncomfortable with the idea of parting with it entirely, there are other options that can provide a smart compromise. One of these is the partial sale. For example, if you own a diamond ring, you can choose to sell just the diamond, keeping the ring and replacing the diamond with another stone.

Additionally, a partial sale can serve as the starting point for creative repurposing. Many people choose to transform inherited jewelry with a more modern design, preserving the sentimental value of the original while giving new life to a cherished memory. This option is particularly suitable when the original design is outdated or when the jewelry shows signs of wear.

Keep or Sell? A Delicate Decision

Deciding how to manage inherited jewelry is a delicate choice, blending both practical and emotional factors. Every situation is unique, and there is no single right answer. Whether you choose to keep or sell a family heirloom, the key is to make an informed decision. Carefully assess both the sentimental and economic value of the piece, consider all available options, and don't hesitate to seek advice from trusted experts.

Do You Need a Professional Appraisal for Your Inherited Jewelry?

For a free, no-obligation estimate, you can contact Auctentic, a company specializing in the appraisal and sale of diamonds and precious jewelry. We’ll help you determine whether a piece has value, verify the authenticity of your inherited jewelry, and, if you decide to proceed with the sale, ensure you get the highest prices on the market.

Get Started